Matthew Simcha


Recent Articles:

NEWS

Drug illegality causes violent subculture

In Monday's column titled "Buy locally grown marijuana," the author contends that marijuana use is immoral because it supports the violent Mexican drug cartels that result in thousands of deaths every year. More specifically, the author writes: "Proponents of the legalization of marijuana often refer to smoking weed as a ‘victimless crime.' This is a glaring oversimplification of the act, one that ignores where the marijuana you are currently smoking may have come from, and what kind of tragic violence was left in its wake." While it is true that marijuana, and illegal drugs as a whole, carry with them a violent subculture, the author fails to consider the true cause of this violence; the fact that the drugs are illegal.

NEWS

Politics become series of movements

With the recent rise of the tea party movement, a very disturbing trend has emerged on the political left. All across liberal TV programs and Web sites, anti-tea party activists have pointed out misspellings on tea partiers' protest signs or inappropriate comments shouted by tea partiers, and used them as ammunition to declare the entire tea party movement stupid and racist. Such inferences are illogical and downright offensive.

NEWS

Politics become series of movements

With the recent rise of the tea party movement, a very disturbing trend has emerged on the political left. All across liberal TV programs and Web sites, anti-tea party activists have pointed out misspellings on tea partiers' protest signs or inappropriate comments shouted by tea partiers, and used them as ammunition to declare the entire tea party movement stupid and racist. Such inferences are illogical and downright offensive.

NEWS

Conservatism not black and white

Arrogance in Political Views is Astounding. Yesterday's column, "Liberal bias among students justified," reflects an all too common view among students these days — that liberals are intellectually superior to everyone else. The author's argument goes essentially like this: College students are generally better thinkers than most people, and college students are generally liberal, so liberal thinking must be better than other views. This argument almost seems too pretentious to truly be made, but let's take a look at some of the things the author actually says.

NEWS

People will literally support anything

 Sure, there are plenty of examples throughout history of people getting behind pretty ridiculous causes. But would it be possible to persuade the masses to support something as ludicrous as a federal ban on water? Believe it or not, not only is it possible — it is rather easy. Earlier this October, two fellow members of Young Americans for Liberty and I went on the steps of Brower Commons on the College Avenue campus with a phony petition to ban the chemical "dihydrogen monoxide." For all you non-chemists out there, that is two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom, better known as H2O or water. We came equipped with flyers that gave facts about this chemical; for example, it is "found in some of the world's most polluted lakes and rivers," and that "powerful special interests want it around for their own benefit." Most people, however, did not even read the flyer before signing our petition. All it took for them was a friendly greeting of "Hey, could you please help us out? We're trying to get a chemical banned that's found in our lakes and rivers," and just like that, they were supporters of the ban. Given the constant rhetoric in the media that makes it sound like a crime to be politically inactive, it is hard to blame these people, who were for the most part very polite and even apologetic after we told them it was all a trick. At the end of the experiment, we were left with 52 signatures on our petition to ban water. The fact that today's youth will get behind any cause without looking into it is very dangerous. Granted, a federal ban on dihydrogen monoxide could never realistically be passed, because once it came out that the chemical was actually water the support would vanish. But what about when the issue is not so simple? Ill-advised actions are taken by governments all around the world simply because the key supporters of these actions are good persuaders. And yet, the media constantly encourage people to just go vote and be politically active, rather than to question things before supporting them. In fact, if you are not questioning a certain part of this article right now, then you still need to work on your critical skepticism. Earlier I wrote, "we were left with 52 signatures on our petition to ban water." Anytime you read an incomplete figure like this, it should raise a red flag. You should be wondering, how long did it take us to get that many signatures? How many people were legitimately skeptical of our proposal? How many people refused to sign? A more complete set of statistics regarding our little experiment is as follows: we were out there for just under 90 minutes going up to people asking them to sign our petition. Of the 60 people who stopped and listened, 52 signed the petition, five correctly identified dihydrogen monoxide as water, two questioned our misleading facts incessantly and refused to sign, and one said she would look up more information and then make a decision. I will let you draw your own conclusions from these numbers. I would like to end with a plea from myself, followed by a plea from one of the most intelligent people to ever have lived. First, I ask that people throw away this mob mentality that seems to run rampant and form their own opinions on issues based upon unbiased research. If you are going to sign a petition, know why. If you do not know, do not sign. If you are going to vote, know why. If you do not know, do not vote. Finally a quote from a man whose intelligence and critical thinking ability has amazed scientists for decades, "the most important thing is to never stop questioning," said Albert Einstein.   Matthew Simcha is a School of Arts and Sciences junior majoring in economics and statistics.  

More Articles


Support Independent Student Journalism

Your donation helps support independent student journalists of all backgrounds research and cover issues that are important to the entire Rutgers community. All donations are tax deductible.